The FTC Takes a Bite Out of Non-Compete Agreements – By Clayton R. Leonard, Esq.
On April 23, 2024, the Federal Trade Commission (“FTC”) dealt a significant blow to non-compete agreements in the United States. The commission voted 3-2 to enact a final rule that broadly bans these clauses in employment contracts. While its future remains uncertain with many likely legal challenges arising, this move is expected to have a major impact on employers across the country.
A Crackdown on Restrictions
Non-compete agreements typically restrict employees from working for a competitor or starting their own competing business for a certain period after leaving their current job. Proponents argue these agreements protect trade secrets, confidential information, and client relationships. However, the FTC’s ruling takes the opposite view, asserting that non-competes stifle worker mobility, suppress wages, and limit innovation.
The new rule prohibits employers from entering into any new non-compete agreements with all workers, regardless of position or seniority. This applies to both full-time and part-time employees. The FTC estimates that roughly 30 million Americans, or one in five workers, were subject to non-competes prior to this ruling.
Existing Agreements: A Distinction is Made
The FTC acknowledges that some existing non-compete agreements may continue to be enforced. The rule treats these differently depending on the employee’s status:
- Senior Executives: Existing non-compete agreements for senior executives, defined as those earning more than $151,164 annually and holding policy-making positions, are still considered enforceable. However, the FTC emphasizes that employers cannot enforce these agreements any more harshly than necessary to protect legitimate business interests.
- Other Workers: Existing non-compete agreements for all other workers are rendered unenforceable after the rule’s effective date, which is 120 days after publication in the Federal Register. Employers are required to rescind these agreements and notify affected workers that the restrictions are no longer valid.
Potential Benefits and Concerns
The FTC’s ruling is expected to have a wide-ranging impact on the American workforce. Here is a brief summary of some potential benefits and concerns:
Benefits:
- Increased Worker Mobility: With non-competes less prevalent, workers will have greater freedom to pursue new opportunities, potentially leading to higher wages and better working conditions.
- Boost to Innovation: Increased worker mobility could lead to a greater flow of ideas and expertise across industries, fostering innovation and entrepreneurship.
- Enhanced Competition: By allowing workers to take their skills to competitors, the FTC believes competition among businesses will be strengthened.
Concerns:
- Trade Secret Protection: Some employers worry that the ruling will make it harder to protect sensitive information and trade secrets from departing employees who may join competitors.
- Loss of Leverage in Negotiations: Employers may feel they have less leverage during contract negotiations without the ability to implement non-competes, potentially impacting training and development programs.
- Legal Challenges: The legality of the FTC’s rule is likely to be challenged in court by business groups who argue the commission is overstepping its authority.
The Road Ahead
The FTC’s ruling on non-compete agreements is a significant development with far-reaching implications. While the potential benefits for worker mobility and innovation are significant, concerns surrounding trade secret protection and legal challenges remain. It is likely to be a lengthy process before the full impact of the ruling becomes clear.
Here are some additional points to consider:
- State Laws: Some states already have laws restricting non-competes, and these will continue to apply alongside the FTC’s rule. In Nevada, noncompetition agreements, their limitations and enforceability, are codified under NRS 613.195.
- Alternative Protections: Businesses may explore alternative ways to protect confidential information, such as stricter confidentiality agreements and non-disclosure agreements.
- Impact on Specific Industries: The impact of the ruling may vary depending on the industry. Industries with a high concentration of trade secrets, such as pharmaceuticals, may be more concerned about the potential for employee mobility.
The FTC’s move represents a major shift in the landscape of non-compete agreements. It remains to be seen how businesses, workers, and the courts will adapt to this new reality.
If you have a non-compete agreement and would like to discuss your situation in more detail with one of our experienced attorneys, please contact our office at your convenience to schedule a free no-obligation consultation.
Schedule a free initial consultation today!
Call our office at 702-690-9090, or reach us online.
